| FIRST NAME | LAST NAME | SCHOOL | YEAR |
| TOM | FISCHER | MANALAPAN | 1981 |
| BRYAN | SPOONIRE | ASBURY PARK | 1989 |
| BRYAN | SPOONIRE | ASBURY PARK | 1990 |
| BRYAN | HEFFERNAN | ASBURY PARK | 1991 |
| EAMON | BLANCHARD | LACEY TWP. | 1994 |
| BRIAN | KERWIN | CHRISTIAN BROTHERS ACADEMY | 1999 |
| CRAIG | FORYS | COLTS NECK | 2005 |
| CRAIG | FORYS | COLTS NECK | 2006 |
| THOMAS | O’NEILL | MIDDLETOWN NORTH | 2012 |
| MIKE | MCCLEMENS | CHRISTIAN BROTHERS ACADEMY | 2013 |
| ELLIOT | GINDI | OCEAN TWP. | 2016 |
| DEVIN | HART | PT. PLEASANT BORO | 2017 |